Best Dress Shoe Insoles: No More Discomfort!

Sometimes you might find your dress shoes cramping your feet making you look fabulous but uncomfortable, after all. This discomfort takes away all the pleasure of looking “dapper”, if I may say. Comfort will always overshadow style but that doesn’t have to be the case! Before you decide to trade your super stylish dress shoes for a more casual option, I know exactly what could fix that discomfort in your feet: Dress Shoe Insoles! Yes, sir. 

A shoe insole serves as a foot-bed to provide extra support, stability and comfort. Now how do we replace the insoles? Simple. Sometimes you don’t have to and most times, the material or insole in good quality shoes will be, almost always, removable. Otherwise you can trim and fit the shoe insoles inside the shoe. Shoe insoles usually last around 6 months on average but if your shoe usage is more frequent and rigorous, then perhaps a change after 4 months would do you good!

There is a variety of insoles by type and by material, for example, Low-Profile Insoles work by providing arch support and this relieves the ache in the forefoot and heel. Just like that you can choose your shoe insoles using this list of top 5 best dress shoe insoles that are going to save you from the discomfort compromising your style.

1. Pinnacle Insole, BLUE, by Powerstep

Best Overall

  • Wide size range
  • Antimicrobial
  • Variable cushioning technology
  • Fabric upper wears out

Material: EVA foam base | Arch Support: Yes | Shipping Weight: N/A | Dimensions: 13.8 x 4.5 x 1.8 inches

Last Update on 2020-10-28 using Amazon Product Advertising API

Starting off with the winner on our list, the best over-all Pinnacle Insole by Powerstep! Made in the USA, these are comfortable insoles for your dress shoes with qualities of being anti-microbial to avoid any kind of bacterial and fungal growth and hence, avoids foot odor. The Pinnacle is a full-length insole, with sizes ranging from 3 to 16+ for men and 5 to 15.5 for women. They are suitable to fit most people.

These shoe insoles provide your dress shoes with maximum cushioning via their EVA foam makeup. They are 0.7” high and 14” wide. These can be broken down into their durable EVA foam base and plush top layer which is backed by the variable cushioning technology promised by the manufacturer to give maximum support to your feet. 

Personally, the dual layer feature of the insoles seemed to have focused cushioning at particular areas of the feet in order to enhance support for my feet. The semi-rigid arch support is firm in its making but provides flexible arch support. The deep heel cradle manages to provide a kind of foot support and stability that improves motion control during physical exertion. This shoe insole has been suitable for all arch types be it low, neutral, or high arches which means that it was the ideal candidate for the variety of dress shoes that I owned. Moreover, the fabric on the insoles keeps the feet pretty dry during use which avoids blisters. 

These insoles are a dream for your dress shoes, though if I really had to point out a shortcoming, it had to be that they are not as durable as you’d expect them to be especially given their fabric upper. Otherwise, these really are the best all in all among the existing insoles out there.

2. Black Premium Insoles by Superfeet

Best Quality

  • High density foam layer
  • Biomechanical shape
  • Odor-control coating
  • Not ideal for wide feet

Material: Synthetic | Arch Support: Yes | Shipping Weight: N/A | Dimensions: N/A

Last Update on 2020-10-28 using Amazon Product Advertising API

Running close and ranking second are the Black Premium Insoles by Superfeet. Superfeet is an expert company in the manufacturing of insoles to provide maximum foot support. The Black Premium Insoles come in Black color and are synthetic made in the USA.

These insoles are low profile which means that they are thin and sleek to fit in your shoes without overcrowding the space in your dress shoes. These insoles have been specifically designed to alleviate stress on knees and ankles, and ultimately the feet. The composition is so that the heel area is rigid but the ball of the foot and toe area is fairly flexible. This rigid heel cup provides stability and support to the feet. Moreover, there is a stabilizer cap for structure and support and a closed-celled foam layer for extra support and cushioning for pain relief.

This purchase felt like a great investment as these low profile full-length insoles are a good fit for dress shoes of all kinds. The support, cushioning and odor control have all been exceptional. The high density foam layer, closed-cell foam technology, provides unparalleled comfort. My feet remain fresh after an entire day’s worth of wearing shoes, and even more, they remain comfortable as the bio-mechanical shape provides flexibility and stabilizes the foot support to exponentially reduce pressures on knees, feet and the legs. The feet never smell due to the odor-control coating!

The only experienced drawback would be that they might seem a little unfit for wider feet. Other than that, these are exceptional quality and value for money! 

3. Holiday Orthotic Inserts by Pedag

Best Eco-friendly

  • Available in a range of sizes/ two colors
  • Tanned leather
  • Fits inside all shoes
  • Run on the small side

Material: Natural | Arch Support: Yes | Shipping Weight: 2.1 ounces | Dimensions:11.5 x 4.5 x 0.2 inches

Last Update on 2020-10-28 using Amazon Product Advertising API

Ranking third on our list are the Holiday Orthotic Inserts by Pedag. These insoles are really something, wait till you read up on their incredible characteristics. The Pedag products are handmade in Germany from natural materials via eco-friendly measures!

These insoles are made from naturally tanned leather and stand out for having the seal of acceptance from the American Podiatric Medical Association. They are also available in black color and a range of sizes for both men’s and women’s dress shoes. These insoles are 3/4th inserts which means that they are pretty slim and won’t change anything about your shoe. These shoe insoles have a unique design that includes the semi-rigid arch, plantar vault support, metatarsal pad (for metatarsal arch) and the heel cushion.

When I wore these inside my dress shoes, I could barely notice them in terms of their lightness but the comfort was outstanding and hence greatly noticeable. The soft pad gives support to the heel, while the semi-rigidity of the foot-bed provides balanced support to the foot. The natural material composition of the shoe insole (Cotton, Bamboo, Wool, Leather, Carbon, Sisal, Cork and Aluminum) made my feet feel fresh at all times no matter how much I kept the shoes on. Moreover, to keep the insoles skin-friendly, water-based adhesives have been used. The adhesive pad on the bottom keeps the insole in place. The leather is also vegetable tanned since chemical tanning can be harmful for the skin. I found it extremely respectable that Pedag had so much consideration for the consumer and the environment.

These shoes are overall great quality and the manufacturer seems to take into consideration the greater well-being of the society. The only drawback I can manage to highlight is that the sizing up should be done in order to find the right size as these shoe insoles can run on the smaller side.

4. Dr. Scholl's AIR-PILLO Insoles

Best Economical

  • Cheap
  • Can be trimmed to fit any shoe
  • Really thin
  • Not long-lasting

Material: Sure Grip Foam | Arch Support: Yes | Shipping Weight: 2.1 ounces | Dimensions: 4 x 0.3 x 14.4 inches

Last Update on 2020-10-28 using Amazon Product Advertising API

With product dimensions of 4 x 0.3 x 14.4 inches and a weight of 1.76 ounces, Dr. Scholl’s AIR-PILLO Insoles rank at number 4! These shoe insoles are super-light, budget-friendly, easy to trim and super soft. Dr. Scholl’s guarantees the product’s quality by providing a “Money-back” guarantee.

These insoles come with two layers of foam for an ultra-soft cushioning effect. This double-layer system comprises a top and bottom layer. The bottom layer is made up of “Sure Grip Foam” which ensures that the insole remains in place without any wrinkling/bunching to avoid discomfort. Moreover, the money back guarantee really puts one’s trust in the purchase of these cost-effective insoles.

Personally, these have been a great choice for my frequently used dress shoes. Since they do wear out eventually but are super cheap, I bought 4 pairs just to stay on the safer side! They are exceptionally light and soft in use. However, it should be noted that the insoles can come stuck together and there shouldn’t be any anxiety pulling them apart as to have a pair. I have trimmed the different pairs to fit into different shoes of my liking and frequent use. 

The Dr. Scholl Air-Pillo Insoles are not most durable insoles, so you can choose over them for frequent use but they are super cheap and can be a great choice if you plan on investing in lighter insoles and don’t mind replacing the insoles after a month or so.

5. Slimfit Orthotic Inserts by Vionic

Best Cost-effective

  • Adhesive pad prevent movement within shoes
  • Cost-effective
  • Toes can slide onto the ruff area
  • Not recommended for higher heels

Material: 100% Polyester | Arch Support: Yes | Shipping Weight: N/A | Dimensions: 10 x 15 x 6 inches

Last Update on 2020-10-28 using Amazon Product Advertising API

Last but not the least, the product wrapping up this special list by none other than Vionic: the Slimfit Orthotic Inserts. These shoe inserts have especially been designed to relieve foot pain from your favorite dress shoes. Vionic presents podiatrist-designed shoes which serve as the best cost-effective alternative to other orthotics.

I noticed that these insoles provide a great deal of support to the feet through their built-in rear-foot angle which allows the realignment of the foot to its natural, best-fit position. This can aid in support to the metatarsal bones, and offers relief from a variety of foot-related conditions. Moreover, the adhesive pad beneath the insoles effectively prevented them from moving in shoes with higher arches. These insoles managed to fit into most of my dress shoes and casual-wear. However, these insoles weren’t really suitable for heels that were relatively higher (than 3 inches, ideally).

All in all, these insoles were extremely comfortable with excellent support at the heel area but the toe area was a little problematic as my toes kept coming in contact with the bottom of the shoe which was uncomfortable sometimes. However, they are still a good grab given their value for money!

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button